Amantani Island - Can Tourism Enhance Culture?

Amantani Island - Cultures Strengthened byin with the footprints of responsible tourism.  We
Tourismsometimes live in a fantasy world imagining that
As the boat cruises slowly across thewithout tourism people would live their lives in
impressively encapsulated Lake Titicaca it is forpeace, traditionally, sustainably, and happy in a
passengers to forget that they are coasting atworld without the stresses of the "real world."  It
3810 meters above sea level.  It would be easyseems, however, that on Amantani Island I have
forgive someone to think that they werefound something to the contrary.
effortlessly sailing along one of the world's  greatAs I sit down with my homestay papa, who tells
seas.  The lake, at one point in histoy, must haveme he is fifty although he looks to be closer to
been covered with a myriad of fishing boats. seventy, I shake his hands and notice that they
Local people have netted these waters for theare warn and rough from long days working the
small native fish that live in its cold waters forterraces of potatoes and of corn.  He begins by
years.  However, recently, these waters havetelling me about how happy he is that we have
been overrun by large kingfish and trout put intocome to stay with them, how much it means to
the lake as a more readily available source oftheir family to be able to earn a small wage. 
protein.  And much like the new foreign fish that"Tenemos todo que necesitamos (we have
are occupying the depths of the water, a neweverything we need)" he tells me in a firm voice
foreign visitor is beginning to grace the surface ofas if reassuring his pride as much as he is letting
its waters as well.me that they don't need us, "we can grow our
The boat begins to approach its islandcrops, drink our sheep's milk, and eat our chicken's
destination.  Women dressed in brightly colouredmeat."  But as he explains, life is much more
clothing that has been inspired by traditional,comfortable than it has been in the past.  He has
Christian, and Muslim influences sit patiently alongseen three of his sons run off to the city of Puno
side the concrete dock awaiting their timid newto work odd jobs for meagre wages amongst
guests.  As they sit, the women's hands are inthe noise and stress.  As they work in the city,
constant motion as they hurry to knit a locallyhe worries, they could lose their birth language of
inspired beanie which they hope to sell to theirQuechua, their traditions, and maybe even their
intrigued visitors.  The foreign guests nervouslyminds.
crawl in to meet their homestay mamas and thenTourism, here on Amantani, seems to be
are quickly whisked away to be shown how thereinforcing the cultural norms of the people.  Each
people live here on Amantani Island.night a local dance is put on by the local
The truth is that most people who arrive to thispopulation.  Locals and guests alike are dressed in
remote island in the middle of the world's highesttraditional garbs as rhythmic tunes of pan flute,
navigable are somewhat expecting the localcharango, and drums entice the people to share
inhabitants to live in completely primitivehands, beers, and dances.  Near the end of the
conditions.  I'd like to believe that it's not the casenight the tourists take seats along the walls of
that people go to these islands in hopes of findingthe community hall as the locals perform local
out that its occupants live in relative poverty, butdances describing work, love, and life.  It would
I'm sure some travelers seek, and maybe evenbe hard to imagine such a cultural exchange
relish in, that situation.  The truth is however,happening on a nightly basis if it weren't for the
that despite the traditional clothing, the jaggedgroups of tourists who grace the island's green
pre-Inca terraces, and stone walls that describeturf each day.
this island, many on the island are living quite aDespite the anticipatory notion that travelers may
modern life.  Much of the new found "luxuries"have in regards to the island the houses aren't
that the local people are beginning to enjoy are arickety old shacks with straw thatched roofs.  In
direct result of the growth of a tourism market.fact, the vast majority of them are well build
Academics and journalist from around the worldcement painted houses, fitted with modern toilets
all so often discount travel as another arm ofand powered by modern solar panels; both of
globalization's or the "Western World's"which are amenities only made possible by the
imperialism.  However, it seems that far tooboat loads of tourist groups and backpackers who
many dispel the possible positive affects broughtseek to understand this lake culture.